Terminale · Lesson 1

Truth Under Attack?

To what extent has the English-speaking world entered a post-truth era?

Your name

1 · Fact or fake?

Tick FACT or FAKE for each statement.

2 · Video: How false news can spread

TED-Ed, Noah Tavlin, 3 min 42. Watch once for the general idea, then a second time to answer.

Video not loading? Open it on YouTube.

3 · Reading: Welcome to the Post-Truth Era

§1 In 2016, Oxford Dictionaries chose post-truth as its word of the year: a situation where emotions and personal beliefs shape public opinion more than facts do. The word was everywhere during the Brexit referendum and the US presidential election.

§2 Lies in politics are nothing new. In 2002, the British government claimed that Iraq had weapons of mass destruction that could be ready “within 45 minutes”. The claim helped to justify the 2003 invasion, but no such weapons were found. In 2016, the Chilcot report said the threat had been presented with far too much certainty.

§3 What is new is how fast false claims travel, and how little it matters when they are exposed. In 2016, a Brexit campaign bus claimed the UK sent the EU £350 million a week; the UK Statistics Authority called the figure misleading, but the slogan stayed. In 2017, the White House claimed Donald Trump’s inauguration crowd was the largest ever, despite the photos. An adviser called this “alternative facts”.

§4 Social media add conspiracy theories. In 2016, a man fired a rifle in a Washington pizza restaurant after reading a false online story, “Pizzagate”. In 2020, the false idea that 5G spread COVID-19 led people to attack more than 50 phone masts in the UK.

§5 False stories work because they are simple, emotional and easy to share, and because we believe what confirms our views. Corrections rarely travel as far as the lie. So the question is not only “Is it true?” but “Why do I want to believe it?”

Glossary: weapons of mass destruction = armes de destruction massive · misleading = trompeur · phone mast = antenne-relais

4 · Be a fact-checker: SIFT

StopInvestigate the sourceFind better coverageTrace the claim

These three posts are invented. For each one, tick ALL the red flags, then say what you would check.